Friday, November 20, 2026
No menu items!

‘We Have Become Afraid’: SMMA Director Tells Boat Collision Inquiry of Threats and Enforcement Gaps

Must Read

The head of the Soufriere Marine Management Association has told the commission investigating the fatal Anse Cochon boat collision that threats against staff and a lack of legal enforcement powers have left his organisation afraid to confront some users of the marine space it is charged with managing.

Harold Dalsan, the association’s Executive Director, said rangers depend heavily on voluntary compliance, while dangerous behaviour and weak coordination between agencies continue to undermine safety.

“We have become timid. We have become afraid to approach some of these guys,” he testified.

Dalsan alleged that individuals had gone to his home to threaten him after the association attempted to stop spearfishing. He also said the chief ranger had been threatened following an intervention on the water.

His evidence placed a troubling question before the inquiry: how can an organisation manage a busy marine area when, according to its director, it lacks the legal tools to compel users to obey?

Dalsan said bylaws intended to strengthen the SMMA’s authority remained unfinished, leaving the association exposed to challenges when attempting to enforce compliance.

“We do not have anything in law vested in us to stop a vessel, to ask for a license,” he told commissioners.

He described the situation as “part of the whole breakdown in the system” and urged the commission to help advance the measures needed to give the organisation legal teeth.

The commission challenged that position, questioning the purpose of deploying seven rangers if users could simply refuse their instructions.

Dalsan acknowledged the limits bluntly. If someone refused to pay or cooperate, he said, there was little the association could do.

The inquiry also examined whether agencies with enforcement powers could act on problems identified by SMMA patrols.

“Unfortunately, no. We work in silos and that has to end,” Dalsan said when asked about that level of collaboration with the Saint Lucia Air and Sea Ports Authority.

He called for clear reporting channels so staff witnessing a speeding vessel would know whom to contact and how to secure a response.

Commissioners also questioned how such gaps could persist when several key agencies were represented on the SMMA’s board. Dalsan said he had observed a renewed commitment from the board, but acknowledged that this had not always been his experience.

During questioning about the collision, the commission put to him that one of the captains involved had a licence that expired 11 years earlier. Dalsan said he had not known that and described the issue of unlicensed operations as deeply concerning.

Beyond licensing, he warned of crowded waters where passenger vessels and swimmers compete for space.

Recalling conditions at Anse Chastanet before an intervention to separate boats from snorkelers, he described vessels operating alongside large numbers of people in the water as “a disaster waiting to happen.”

A line introduced to separate those activities had helped, he said, but some vessels had crossed it.

Dalsan urged the creation of marked lanes for vessels entering and leaving Soufriere Bay, alongside navigational aids and consideration of a wider coastal corridor for small commercial vessels.

He also called for organised mooring arrangements, warning that improvised moorings and poorly maintained equipment could allow boats to break free and cause further harm.

His proposals included tickets for minor infractions, stronger checks when licences are issued or renewed, and regular meetings involving marine users and enforcement agencies.

Commissioners pressed him to pursue closer cooperation with the Soufriere police, pointing out that local officers also have a responsibility to enforce the law within the bay.

Dalsan agreed to take that discussion forward. He said the importance of marine activities to Saint Lucia’s tourism industry demanded corresponding investment in safety, monitoring and enforcement.

Urging the inquiry to turn the tragedy into meaningful reform, he said: “That should never happen again.”

Latest News

Thinking About Your Next Degree? This Edinburgh Napier Graduate Went From Self-Doubt to Distinction

At 40, Emmanuella Ferdinand has a message for adults wondering whether it's too late to further their education: “Don’t...

More Articles Like This