Saint Lucia’s Allen Chastanet has joined four Eastern Caribbean opposition leaders in demanding that governments disclose what they have told the European Union about the future of Citizenship by Investment programmes—and how they would protect jobs, public services and investment if that revenue declines.
In a joint statement dated November 18, the leaders called for immediate parliamentary explanations of governments’ positions, any commitments already made and the timelines under discussion.
Their central question: what has been agreed in citizens’ names, and what would the consequences be?
The statement follows what the leaders described as a November 12 deadline for governments to communicate their positions on an EU request to phase out the programmes.
The leaders stressed that the deadline was not an automatic shutdown date for citizenship programmes or an automatic end to visa-free travel.
For Saint Lucia, their demands include disclosure of the government’s response to the EU, a detailed assessment of public finances exposed to CIP revenue, and an explanation of how essential services and existing projects would be funded if that income falls or ends.
“Diplomatic confidentiality cannot justify indefinite secrecy about decisions with such far-reaching national consequences,” the statement said.
The signatories acknowledged what they described as St Kitts and Nevis’ announced decision to wind down its programme on a negotiated timetable, and Antigua and Barbuda’s stated intention to do likewise while seeking a longer transition. They called on other governments to explain their own positions and commitments.
Banking was another major concern.
Citing a risk to correspondent banking relationships raised by the prime minister of St Kitts and Nevis, the leaders warned that disruptions could affect remittances, payments for imports, tourism receipts and other international transactions.
However, they urged governments to distinguish confirmed threats from potential risks and clarify whether any specific warnings had come from foreign authorities, regulators or correspondent banks. They explicitly cautioned against suggesting that losing visa-free access would automatically mean losing banking relationships.
The group called for a coordinated assessment involving the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank and the banking sector, alongside contingency measures to protect households and businesses.
They also want a comprehensive financial assessment and audit covering CIP-dependent revenue and expenditure, associated fund balances, and outstanding obligations to developers and infrastructure projects.
During any transition, the leaders argued, governments must maintain strict due diligence, transparent accounting and independent oversight. They opposed discounting, rushed approvals and new commitments that could leave taxpayers carrying obligations without secure financing.
While acknowledging that Citizenship by Investment has contributed to regional development, the signatories said that contribution must be weighed against dependence on the programmes and a changing international environment.
They called for a common regional negotiating position seeking a fair transition, development assistance and sustainable investment alternatives, supported by economic plans developed with businesses, workers and civil society.
The statement also urged the EU to recognise small island states’ economic vulnerabilities and help develop practical alternatives to the financing it is asking countries to relinquish.
Joining Chastanet as signatories were Adrian Joseph of Grenada, Carriacou and Petit Martinique; Jamale Pringle of Antigua and Barbuda; People’s Action Movement leader Shawn Richards of St Kitts and Nevis; and United Workers Party leader Thomson Fontaine of Dominica.




