Human rights attorney Mary Francis has expressed strong disappointment with Prime Minister Philip J. Pierre’s response to reporters on Monday, regarding the announced disappearance and subsequent resurfacing of critical evidence linked to two high-profile cases.
Speaking to Saint Lucia Daily Post, Francis described the Prime Minister’s reaction as “pathetic” and “uninspiring,” stressing that in her personal view, his response fell short of the leadership expected from someone holding both the offices of Prime Minister and Minister for National Security.
“When asked a straightforward question — whether he could confirm if the evidence was found — the Prime Minister could have answered yes, no, or given a brief explanation,” Francis said. “Instead, in my opinion, he went into what I would call a political diatribe, leaning on separation of powers in a way that I believe does not apply in this context.”
Francis emphasized that as the head of government and the minister responsible for national security, the Prime Minister carries an ultimate duty to ensure public confidence in the justice system.
“In my view, the executive has a responsibility to seek clarification when things go wrong, particularly in matters as serious as missing evidence,” she explained. “The people of Saint Lucia deserve transparency, and without it, confidence in our institutions will erode”.
Francis also highlighted the contradictory reports surrounding the handling of the evidence. According to her, statements made by the police, government officials, and even members of Parliament have raised more questions than answers.
“The public needs clarity,” she said. “We cannot have governance marked by confusion and contradictory information. It threatens democracy when citizens cannot trust the information they receive.”
Francis tied the issue to St. Lucia’s broader human rights record, pointing to recommendations from the IMPACS investigation in 2015, which included strengthening security around evidence storage and improving oversight of exhibits.
“For years, there have been calls to improve the security of evidence rooms,” she noted. “When evidence in high-profile cases goes missing or its whereabouts are unclear, it undermines not just the justice system but also St. Lucia’s credibility on the international stage.”
Francis urged Prime Minister Pierre to revisit his response and issue a comprehensive statement addressing the matter, reassuring the public that corrective steps are being taken.
“The Prime Minister is the captain of the ship,” she said. “In my opinion, he has an obligation to lead with transparency and accountability. Anything less risks weakening the justice system and undermines public trust.”
